Methodology & Checks

Which objects need a classification, a material and properties

Summary

Several checks in the report ask the same question: how many objects carry a classification, a material, quantities or property values? The answer depends on which objects you count. Some never need these things: their IFC class already says what they are, they are props rather than assets, or they are not real objects at all. A chair needs no classification code to be a chair, a tree needs no material, and an opening in a wall is a hole.

Counting such objects would make a model look worse than it is, and sometimes better. So the coverage figures count only the objects that need what is being measured. This article lists which objects are left out, for which of the four, and how assemblies, rebar and fittings are treated.

The idea behind the rules: an object is left out when its IFC class already says enough about it, or when it is not a real object at all. Everything else counts.

Where you see it in the report

PlaceWhat changes
Information page, card Coverage per classClasses that need nothing show not needed instead of a percentage. A footnote says when furniture, vegetation, openings or assemblies are left out of the percentages.
Checks Classification coverage, Material coverage, Quantity coverage and Effective facts per elementMeasured over the objects that need a classification, a material, quantities or property values.
Check Share of unclassified proxies, and the effective proxy share on the check cards and the Capabilities pageUnclassified proxies that are recognised as trees, terrain, people or cars are not counted as unclassified. Share of proxies still counts them in its value.
Scores page, What makes up the Forensic BIM score™Completeness and Richness use the same coverage figures.
Capabilities pageConditions such as Classified ≥ 80%, Materials ≥ 80% and Unclassified proxies ≤ 2% of elements use the same figures.

Other checks still look at every element. A chair without geometry is missing geometry, and a tree with a duplicate GlobalId is a duplicate.

Objects that need none of the four

These objects are left out of classification, material, quantity and property coverage:

ObjectsIFC classesStill counted
The project and the spatial containers around and inside a facilityIfcProject, IfcSite, IfcBuildingStorey, IfcFacilityPart (bridge, road, railway and marine parts), IfcExternalSpatialElementThe facility itself (IfcBuilding, IfcBridge, IfcRoad and so on) and its spaces still need a classification.
Openings and other cut-outsIfcOpeningElement, IfcVoidingFeature, IfcProjectionElement–
Virtual elementsIfcVirtualElement–
FurnitureIfcFurnishingElement and its subtypesA technical cabinet (IfcFurniture of type TECHNICALCABINET, IFC 4.3) holds equipment that is maintained, so it counts.
Vegetation and terrainIfcGeographicElementA soil boring point (SOIL_BORING_POINT) counts.
Trees, planting, terrain, people and cars modelled as generic objectsIfcBuildingElementProxy, IfcCivilElement or IfcBuiltElement, recognised by name (see below)–

Annotations, grids, ports, alignments and referents, and structural analysis items are never counted as elements in the first place.

Generic objects recognised by name

IFC2X3 has no class for vegetation, and many tools export trees, terrain, entourage people and cars as generic proxies. The audit recognises them by the object’s name, its object type, its type name or the category the authoring tool wrote as a property (for example Revit’s Planting, Topography and Entourage). It looks for whole words in English, Dutch, German and French: tree, boom, Baum, arbre, shrub, hedge, grass, terrain, topography, maaiveld, person, pedestrian, car, vehicle, bicycle and similar. Tree_03 matches; Street does not.

Some words make it a real object again, because the thing is maintained: tree grate, car park barrier and person lift still count, as do names with words such as gate, paving, light, pole, sign, drain, pipe, cable or sensor. These words do not override the authoring tool’s category: a generic object whose category is Planting, Topography or Entourage is left out whatever its name. Name rules are a rule of thumb; giving trees and terrain their proper class (IfcGeographicElement in IFC4 and later) removes the guesswork.

Recognised proxies are left out of the coverage figures and are not counted as unclassified proxies. They still count in the value of Share of proxies, which shows how much of the model uses generic objects at all; when no unclassified proxy is left, that check is shown for information only.

Assemblies

An assembly (IfcElementAssembly), such as a truss, a prefabricated stair or a precast deck segment, is made of its parts, and the parts carry most of the information.

  • Material: never counted. An assembly should have none; one that has a material is shown under Assemblies with a material, for information only. See Materials in IFC.
  • Classification and property values: counted only when the assembly has them. An assembly without them is left out, so missing data on an assembly never costs points; one that has them counts like any other element.
  • Quantities, such as a total weight or length, still count.

Classification not needed per piece

Nobody classifies single reinforcing bars or bolts; what they are belongs on their type. Reinforcing bars and meshes, fasteners, mechanical fasteners and discrete accessories (IfcReinforcingBar, IfcReinforcingMesh, IfcFastener, IfcMechanicalFastener, IfcDiscreteAccessory) need no classification of their own. They still need a material, quantities and property values. Expansion joints and rail equipment modelled as discrete accessories are maintained assets, so they still need a classification.

Classification stored somewhere else

A classification also counts when it sits on a related object:

  • A part of an aggregate, such as a stair flight, curtain wall panel, wall part or assembly part, is classified when its parent is.
  • A parent is classified when all its parts that need a classification are.
  • A pipe, duct or cable fitting (IfcFlowFitting) is classified when a system it belongs to is.

A classification on the object’s type counts as well, as it always has. Classification in IFC explains how classification is stored.

What the rules do to the figures

Leaving objects out can move a coverage figure either way. In a file whose furniture had no materials, material coverage goes up. In a file where the trees or the furniture were the objects that did carry a classification or a material, it goes down, because those objects no longer prop up the share. That is intended: the figure should describe the objects an owner actually needs information about.

A file in which no object needs what is being measured, for example a furniture library or a planting plan, is judged on all its objects rather than left without a figure.

The rules are applied when a file is examined. Reports made before they were introduced keep their old figures until the file is examined again; upload it with Examine a model to see it on the current rules.

Frequently asked questions

Why did my classification coverage go down when I examined the file again?

Most likely because objects that are now left out, such as furniture or trees, were classified while the rest of the model was not. The new figure describes the objects that need a classification.

Our contract requires furniture to be classified. Does the report ignore that?

The coverage figures leave furniture out, and Coverage per class shows the furniture classes with their element counts but not needed instead of percentages. If your requirements go further than the general rule, check the file against them with an IDS.

A real object was recognised as a tree or a car. What now?

The name rules look at generic objects only. Give the object its proper IFC class, or a name, type and authoring-tool category that say what it is, and it will be counted.