Methodology & Checks

Materials in IFC: coverage, hygiene and names

Summary

A material tells you what an element is made of: concrete, steel, timber, mineral wool. Cost estimates, carbon and life-cycle calculations, fire-safety checks, product passports and maintenance plans all start from it. An element without a material cannot take part in any of them, however good its shape is.

The report looks at materials in four checks. Material coverage on the Information page measures how many elements that need a material have one. Three checks on the Consistency page look at whether the materials can be trusted: Material hygiene (placeholder assignments and unused materials), Material names tidy (near-duplicates, stray spaces and placeholder names) and, for information only, Assemblies with a material.

Furniture, vegetation, openings and assemblies need no material of their own, so they are left out of the coverage figure. Which objects need a classification, a material and properties has the full list.

Where you see it in the report

PlaceWhat it shows
Information page, check Material coverage (marked key)The share of elements with a material, for example 88% of elements.
Information page, card Coverage per classThe Materials column per IFC class, with not needed for classes that need none. The filter Missing materials shows the classes that are not complete.
Information page, card Most used materialsThe ten materials assigned most often, with the number of assignments.
Consistency page, checks Material hygiene, Material names tidy and Assemblies with a materialPlaceholder assignments, unused materials, near-duplicate and placeholder names, and assemblies that carry a material.
Consistency page, card Material namesThe near-duplicates side by side, the placeholder names and the names with double or trailing spaces, plus the counts behind both hygiene checks.
Scores page, card What makes up the Forensic BIM score™Material coverage is one of the three coverages averaged in the Completeness factor.
Capabilities pageMaterials (silver from 90%, gold from 99.5%), Materials + URI, and the condition Materials ≥ 80% for Take-off ready and Energy analysis, or Materials ≥ 90% for Product passport. The last two are draft rules.
In short page, Does it follow common library definitions?How many of the file’s materials link to a dictionary, for example None of the 42 materials link to a dictionary.
Potential pageAn action such as Assign materials (or layer sets) to all physical elements. when a material check scores below 80, with the points it would add to Overall quality.

How a material is counted

IFC can attach a material in several ways: one material, a layer set for walls, slabs and roofs (each layer with its own material and thickness), a profile set for beams and columns, a constituent set for an element made of several materials, or a plain list. The report counts all of them. A material on the element’s type counts for the element too, so a wall type with a layer set gives every wall of that type a material.

The report does not judge whether the material is the right one. It checks that there is one, that its name means something, and that the material list is clean. Whether “C30/37” is the right concrete for a column is a question for the designer.

Material coverage

The share of elements that need a material and have one, on the element or through its type. The score is that share: 88% of elements gives 88. The check has a weight of 1.5, which is why it is marked key, and it belongs to the Information dimension, which counts double in the Overall quality score.

Material coverage also feeds the Forensic BIM score™: its Completeness factor is the average of material, quantity and classification coverage. Raising material coverage from 40% to 100%, with the other two unchanged, adds 6 points to the Forensic BIM score™.

Only elements that need a material are counted. Furniture, vegetation and terrain, generic objects recognised as people, cars or other props, openings, virtual elements and assemblies are left out; a stair flight or a wall still counts when its parent is an assembly. A file in which no element needs a material, for example a file of furniture only, is judged on all its elements rather than left without a figure. Reports made before this rule was introduced keep their old figure, measured over all elements, until the file is examined again.

Material hygiene

Two kinds of clutter in the material list:

  • Placeholder assignments: elements whose material has a name that says nothing, such as Default, Generic, Undefined, By Category, Material, Standaard, a bare number, Building material or Material 2. Each assignment is counted, so one placeholder used on 500 walls counts 500 times.
  • Unused materials: materials that are declared in the file but assigned to no element, directly or through its type. They usually come from a template or a library that was never purged.

Points come off in proportion to the number of placeholder assignments, compared with the number of elements that have a material: 5 points for every 1%, at most 50. Another 10 points come off when there is any unused material. A file with 20 placeholder assignments on 1,000 elements with a material, and a few unused materials, scores 80. The check has a weight of 0.5 and belongs to the Consistency dimension. It is one of the hygiene checks described in Scoring versions and what changed: a pass counts for a quarter of its weight, a failure for its full weight. It is not scored when no element has a material.

Material names tidy

This check reads the names of the materials that are assigned to elements, up to the 50 used most often, and looks for three problems:

ProblemExamplePoints off
Near-duplicates: names that are the same once case, extra spaces and a trailing single digit are ignoredConcrete, concrete and Concrete 18 per group
Stray spaces: two or more spaces in a row inside a name, or an invisible character such as a byte-order mark at either endMineral  wool3 per name
Placeholder namesNames that start with Default, Material, None or IFC building material, Archicad’s Empty Fill or Lege arcering, or a name in angle brackets such as <By Category>10 per name

The score starts at 100 and does not go below 20. The check has a weight of 0.5, belongs to the Consistency dimension, and is not scored when no element has a material.

Near-duplicates matter more than they look. Anything that groups or costs by material name treats Concrete and Concrete 1 as two materials, so one line in a bill of quantities or a carbon report becomes two, and neither total is right.

Assemblies with a material

An assembly (IfcElementAssembly), such as a truss, a prefabricated stair or a bridge deck segment, is made of its parts, and the parts carry the material. A material on the assembly itself repeats what its parts say, and a material take-off can count it twice. Assemblies are therefore left out of material coverage: a model is never marked down for an assembly without a material.

When assemblies do carry a material, the Consistency page shows Assemblies with a material, for example 12 of 40 assemblies. It is shown for information only and has no score. The advice is to put the material on the parts.

Materials that link to a dictionary

A material name is only text. A material that is classified with a reference carrying a URI, for example to a material in the buildingSMART Data Dictionary (bSDD), says exactly which material is meant, in a way software can look up. The report counts the share of declared materials with such a link. It is not part of the material checks, but it decides the Materials + URI capability and shows on the In short page. Classification in IFC explains URIs and bSDD.

Why materials matter after handover

UseWhat a missing or untidy material does
Cost estimates and quantitiesQuantities are priced per material. Without one, the element has no price; with near-duplicates, one material is priced twice or split over two lines.
Carbon and life-cycle assessmentEmbodied carbon is volume times a factor per material. Elements without a material drop out of the total without warning.
Fire safety and building physicsFire resistance, thermal and acoustic checks need to know what each layer is made of. A layer set with placeholder materials gives a thickness without meaning.
Maintenance and replacementInspection intervals, service lives and replacement costs depend on the material. An asset register without materials can’t plan them.
Product passports and circularityReuse and recycling start from knowing which materials are in the asset and where.

How to fix it

  • Assign materials in the authoring tool, preferably on types. A material on a wall, slab or beam type reaches every element of that type, and the file stays consistent.
  • Export layer and profile sets. Most tools can write the layers of walls, slabs and roofs and the profiles of beams and columns to IFC; check that the export settings include them.
  • Replace placeholders. Default, Generic and By Category mean the material was never chosen. Pick the real material, or leave the element out of the export if it should not be there.
  • Merge near-duplicates and purge unused materials before export, so the material list matches what is in the model.
  • Put materials on the parts of an assembly, not on the assembly.
  • Link materials to a dictionary where your organisation or the project requires it, for example by classifying them with a bSDD reference.

Upload the corrected file with Examine a model to see the effect.

Frequently asked questions

My furniture has no materials. Does that lower the score?

No. Furniture, vegetation, openings and assemblies are left out of material coverage. Coverage per class marks furniture, vegetation and assemblies not needed in the Materials column; openings are not listed there at all.

Does a material on the type count?

Yes. An element counts as having a material when it has one itself or inherits one from its type.

Why did my material coverage go down after examining the file again?

Coverage is now measured over the elements that need a material. If the furniture or the trees were the elements that carried materials, leaving them out lowers the share. Examining the file again uses the current rules.

Does the report check that the material is correct?

No. It checks that a material is there, that its name means something and that the list is tidy. Whether it is the right material is a design question.